kung fu panda mission: impossible ii movie download trainspotting fight club movie download lock stock and two smoking barrels movie download heima gone baby gone movie download planet of the apes shakespeare in love movie download apocalypse now movie download harry potter and the prisoner of azkaban hannah montana: the movie movie download movie download x-men: the last stand movie download echelon conspiracy monsters inc. movie download movie download singin' in the rain movie download the incredible hulk blade runner (final cut) coraline the 40 year old virgin movie download the darjeeling limited terminator 2: judgment day schindler's list south park: bigger longer & uncut leaving las vegas movie download movie download frost/nixon 007 goldeneye movie download chicago angels & demons movie download ice age a bug's life movie download paul blart: mall cop mulholland dr. movie download home alone race to witch mountain movie download movie download ocean's twelve the hangover movie download the english patient movie download million dollar baby movie download night at the museum 2: battle of the smithsonian movie download it's a wonderful life movie download movie download star wars: episode iv - a new hope star wars: episode i - the phantom menace movie download star trek movie download signs movie cruel intentions good will hunting movie download van helsing hulk star trek: first contact movie download a beautiful mind movie download a clockwork orange movie download the godfather: part ii stand by me the man from earth movie download movie download desperado dead set movie download movie download my friends tigger & pooh's friendly tails robot chicken: star wars movie download v for vendetta children of men movie download the shawshank redemption movie download the shining movie download dead like me indiana jones and the last crusade movie download fired up movie download black hawk down movie download the usual suspects the blair witch project movie download romeo + juliet artificial intelligence: ai movie download movie download the international the bridge on the river kwai movie download the hunt for gollum movie download monsters vs. aliens the matrix transformers movie download austin powers: international man of mystery movie download dog days of summer slumdog millionaire movie download movie download hotel rwanda bride wars borat movie download vertigo movie download letters from iwo jima baraka movie download the nightmare before christmas movie download edward scissorhands men in black movie download dead poets society collateral back to the future movie download the bourne ultimatum movie download underworld movie download harry potter and the order of the phoenix shelter movie download wall-e harry potter and the sorcerer's stone movie download movie download the grudge 3 the nines movie download movie download the notebook bridget jones's diary movie download scary movie back to the future part ii erin brockovich movie download 2001: a space odyssey movie download the devil's advocate movie download garden state ferris bueller's day off charlie's angels movie download movie download lawrence of arabia the fast and the furious movie download hotel for dogs the green mile movie download the conversation movie download before the devil knows you're dead movie download movie download futurama: bender's big score ben-hur: a tale of the christ movie download movie download the pianist changeling movie download land of the lost movie download the departed natural born killers movie download movie download closer movie the african queen movie download the matrix revolutions the great escape movie download movie download rocky the terminator the island movie download chasing amy movie download the dark knight glory blade runner there's something about mary movie download mean girls donnie darko atonement movie download 300 spartans movie download citizen kane movie download movie download the others the insider movie download saw once upon a time in america silent hill life is beautiful movie download boy a spider-man movie download die hard 2 movie download gladiator the 10th kingdom tales of the black freighter movie download superman returns movie download movie download saving private ryan movie download x-men harry potter and the chamber of secrets movie download requiem for a dream movie download the chimes at midnight kill bill: vol. 1 movie download the apartment movie download as good as it gets movie download anchorman: the legend of ron burgundy taxi driver apocalypto movie download movie download penelope movie download pirates of the caribbean: at world's end casino royale movie download scream movie download obsessed the chronicles of narnia: the lion witch and the wardrobe almost famous shrek 2 movie download in bruges office space movie download the incredibles movie download movie download futurama: into the wild green yonder star wars: episode ii - attack of the clones movie download movie download watchmen from dusk till dawn carlito's way movie download the leon (professional) braveheart movie download i am legend big fish rambo serenity raiders of the lost ark american psycho movie download kill bill: vol. 2 movie download troy fahrenheit 9/11 movie download mystic river bootmen movie download gandhi movie download robin hood: prince of thieves the mummy movie download the final inquiry one flew over the cuckoo's nest movie download l.a. confidential stardust movie download se7en notting hill movie download in cold blood love actually movie download the christmas toy the lord of the rings: the fellowship of the ring movie download platoon ace ventura: pet detective jr. alien movie download gran torino unforgiven movie movie download movie download pearl harbor batman begins movie download the skeptic die another day the third man movie download movie download on the waterfront the ghosts of girlfriends past napoleon dynamite movie download casablanca movie download spider-man 2 journal of a contract killer movie download the last samurai fargo movie download the fifth element making waves movie download 21 grams jurassic park movie download movie download paths of glory movie download reservoir dogs iron man no country for old men finding nemo movie download crank 2: high voltage memento movie download the silence of the lambs movie download the savages terminator 3: rise of the machines movie download the prestige red is the color of movie download rain man movie download green street hooligans 2 movie download the visitor moulin rouge! sweeney todd: the demon barber of fleet street movie download he's just not that into you knocked up heat movie download chop shop forrest gump movie download hot fuzz movie download saw ii movie download aliens speed movie movie download movie download unbreakable movie download war of the worlds movie download lost in translation the elite squad movie download batman forever movie download cool hand luke soldier's girl movie download movie download fast & furious 4 the hurt locker movie download hancock movie download jeff dunham: arguing with myself pirates of the caribbean: dead man's chest movie download jaws movie download adventureland gone in sixty seconds sin city movie download movie download confessions of a shopaholic superbad madea goes to jail movie download munich knowing movie download movie download state of play movie download the godfather: part iii control movie download juno underworld: rise of the lycans the truman show movie download raging bull the lord of the rings: the return of the king movie download the passion of the christ die hard movie download before sunset movie download movie download sleepy hollow austin powers: the spy who shagged me movie download movie download traffic movie movie download once upon a time in the west movie download beauty and the beast the godfather movie download waterworld star wars: episode iii - revenge of the sith movie download i'm not there movie download the pursuit of happyness ocean's eleven movie download if i didn't care movie download minority report movie download movie download five minutes of heaven movie download new in town aka chilled in miami interview with the vampire: the vampire chronicles movie download indiana jones and the kingdom of the crystal skull american pie movie download movie download bruce almighty star wars: episode v - the empire strikes back movie download movie download i robot movie download armageddon the phantom of the opera man on wire movie download the aviator the telling pink panther 2 gangs of new york movie download finding neverland movie download toy story dances with wolves movie download goodfellas movie download the rock movie download howl's moving castle movie download 17 again movie download x-men origins: wolverine the bourne identity movie download spider-man 3 movie download movie download dr. strangelove or: how i learned to stop worrying and love the bomb twelve monkeys the big lebowski movie download rear window vanilla sky the uninvited movie download american gangster dogma movie download aladdin movie download dragonball: evolution movie download enchanted movie download to kill a mockingbird the curious case of benjamin button lara croft: tomb raider road to perdition movie download 12 rounds movie download psycho little miss sunshine movie download movie download ratatouille movie download amadeus jackie brown movie download movie download american beauty movie download the talented mr. ripley drag me to hell movie download the lord of the rings: the two towers groundhog day movie download toy story 2 movie download lesbian vampire killers movie download x2 indiana jones and the temple of doom movie download lucky number slevin movie download movie download how the grinch stole christmas! the last king of scotland movie download movie download star wars: episode vi - return of the jedi city of god movie download catch me if you can pulp fiction movie download shrek movie download life of brian movie download the fugitive movie download 12 angry men there will be blood brokeback mountain movie download movie download independence day movie download the planets harry potter and the goblet of fire movie download the da vinci code movie download movie download the sixth sense movie download the wrestler street fighter: the legend of chun-li movie download notorious movie download movie download pirates of the caribbean: the curse of the black pearl the matrix reloaded movie download movie download the wild bunch blood diamond movie download movie download o brother where art thou? the untouchables 3:10 to yuma movie download winnie the pooh un-valentine's day movie download gone with the wind the simpsons movie movie download the butterfly effect movie download eternal sunshine of the spotless mind ed wood movie download movie download live free or die hard movie download the diving bell and the butterfly the princess bride movie download movie download last chance harvey fear and loathing in las vegas christmas in south park movie download the snowman american history x movie download movie download cloverfield terminator salvation movie download snatch. movie download full metal jacket the elephant man movie download movie download the sting movie download sleuth movie download being john malkovich movie download some like it hot sicko movie download titanic

H.R. 3962 – The Health Insurance Exchange and Public Option

Print This Post Print This Post

By Mitch Gurney

November 8, 2009

I have been reviewing H.R. 3962 (PDF), which passed over the weekend, plus a couple of other reports to better understand the roles and functions of the Health Insurance Exchange and the public option as outlined in the bill. In addition to the bill itself, the two other reports I utilized for this commentary were the HR 3962 Summary Analysis (PDF) and the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) Oct 29th analysis (PDF) of HR 3962.

The purpose of the bill and overall objectives are explained in the first opening pages as follows:

PURPOSE: (1) IN GENERAL -The purpose of this division [Health Choices Administration] is to provide affordable, quality health care for all Americans and reduce the growth in health care spending. BUILDING ON CURRENT SYSTEM – This division achieves this purpose by building on what works in today’s health care system, while repairing the aspects that are broken.

Some of the provisions in H.R. 3962 are designed to increase the number of legal U.S. residents that have health insurance. With that objective in mind it authorizes the government to establish a Health Insurance Exchange to facilitate the offering of health insurance choices available to individuals and employers and would subsidize the purchase of health insurance through the exchange for qualified individuals and families with income between 150 percent and 400 percent of the federal poverty level (FPL). (FPL currently is $16,200 for an individual and $33,100 for a family of 4). The Health Choices Commissioner would obtain bids, negotiate and enter into contracts with qualified plan providers plus define and standardize three different levels of benefits; basic, enhanced, and premium to be offered on the exchange. (See Title III- Subtitle A – Health Insurance Exchange Sec. 301 – 311, pgs 155- 210). There is a fourth tier called premium-plus and these packages can offer extra benefits like dental or vision.

Both individuals and employers will be permitted to participate in the exchange selecting the benefit plan that best fit their budgets and health needs. In the first year individuals not enrolled in other acceptable coverage as well as small employers with 25 or fewer employers will be permitted into the exchange. Access to participate in the exchange will be expanded to include employers with 100 and fewer employees by year 3 following enactment of the legislation with the eventual goal of allowing all employers access to the exchange. Companies may elect to participate in the exchange or continue coverage through currently established methods. Individuals may chose plans offered through their employers or decline them and may instead enter the exchange choosing plans it offers or may purchase insurance plans directly from insurance providers outside the exchange.    

Setting aside for a moment any debates or phobias one might have with government involvement and evaluating this concept from a purely economic perspective it is possible that based on the potential size of the collective pool of premium paying participants on a national level that premiums for these various plans could be less costly to individuals and small employers who otherwise pay higher premiums. It is extremely difficult for individuals to plan and budget for the unpredictable high cost of major illness. We have all heard the saying “there is strength in numbers.” The basic premise of insurance is to take care of these high cost by averaging them in with all cost thereby everyone could be protected against large losses by paying a premium related to these averaged cost. Obviously the larger the pool is of premium payers the more these costs can be averaged out thus lowering the premiums for each participant. Currently and based on this theory that is how an employer with 5000 employees is able to garner lower premiums for their employees versus an employer with 200 employees. If we extrapolate this cost sharing out on a national level the concept behind the federal governments exchange is to eliminate this disparity plus lower the cost of medical expenses in general by averaging these costs out over a much larger population and participation as compared to how it is done today. The aspiration being that if premiums are lower for everyone, more people can afford them and be covered.          

The bill contains a number to consumer protections, like a ban on pre-existing conditions. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) in its Oct 29th analysis (PDF) of HR 3962 explains:

Policies purchased through the exchanges (or directly from insurers) would have to meet several requirements: In particular, insurers would have to accept all applicants, could not limit coverage for preexisting medical conditions, and could not vary premiums to reflect differences in enrollees’ health. The options available in the insurance exchange would include private health insurance plans as well as a public plan that would be administered by the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS).

The public option in HR 3962 will not achieve universal coverage that a single payer option would but as outlined in the act authorizes the government to begin offering public health insurance plans beginning in 2013 as an alternative choice within the exchange thus competing with plans offered by participating private insurance companies in the exchange. (See Subtitle B – Public Health Insurance Option, Sec. 322-331, pgs 211 – 225). The public option would be required to participate on a level playing field with those of the private choices offered on the exchange and like the private plans it must offer the same benefits and abide by the same insurance market reforms. The public option will not be government funded but will be entirely financed by individual premiums, like private plans. Rather than use Medicare’s reimbursement rates plus 5 percent the Commissioner will negotiate rates with health care providers just like private insurance companies do. In Title III-Subtitle A – Health Insurance Exchange Sec. 308 authorizes states to offer their own insurance exchanges or join a group of states to create their own exchanges in lieu of the federal exchange.        

According to the CBO report:

The public plan would negotiate payment rates with all providers and suppliers of health care goods and services; providers would not be required to participate in the public plan in order to participate in Medicare. The public plan would have to charge premiums that covered its costs, including the costs of paying back start-up funding that the government would provide.

This approach is considered by some to be a less competitive threat to private insurance companies who participate in the exchange or in the open market and may put to rest some of the concerns of a government take over of the heath insurance industry. The CBO report notes:

…a public [option] plan paying negotiated rates would attract a broad network of providers but would typically have premiums that are somewhat higher than the average premiums for the private plans in the exchanges. The rates the public plan pays to providers would, on average, probably be comparable to the rates paid by private insurers participating in the exchanges. The public plan would have lower administrative costs than those private plans but would probably engage in less management of utilization by its enrollees and attract a less healthy pool of enrollees. (The effects of those “adverse selection” on the public plan’s premiums would be only partially offset by the “risk adjustment” procedures that would apply to all plans operating in the exchanges.)

OpenCongress.org had observed in their October 31 commentary “Is a Public Option with Negotiated Rates Worthless:”

Making insurance more affordable for sick people is, of course, a good thing, but it’s not really what the public option was meant to do in the greater health care reform picture. It’s supposed to offer cheaper insurance and encourage the private companies to find ways to lower their own prices in order to stay competitive. CBO has previously estimated (PDF) that [a more]…“robust” public option plan would [have been]…able to offer premiums …about 10 percent cheaper than what private companies charge currently. But this new public option with negotiated rates is going [to] mean that the health care bill, with its individual mandate, will be forcing healthy people that are currently choosing not to pay hundreds of dollars a month for insurance, to buy insurance without making any cheaper options available to them.

Now that The House has passed their bill this process is only half over. Now all eyes will be on the Senate as they debate their bill in the next few weeks. But if enacted everyone would be mandated to get insurance or face being taxed a proposed 2.5% tax on individual’s adjusted gross income. The bill authorizes however for the Department of Treasury and the Exchange to establish hardship exemption from the additional individual tax. Employers may elect to provide coverage to their employees and for those that elect not to provide coverage the bill establishes a payroll tax of 8% that phases in for small employers with annual payroll from $500,000 through $750,000. Employers with an annual payroll less than $500,000 will be exempt from the tax. For individuals who decline their employer’s coverage offering, the act requires the employer to contribute a proposed 8 percent contribution of the average salary for the employer to the exchange.

OpenCongress.org  points out:

The Senate is still weeks away from beginning debate on their own health care bill. The final details of their bill are still being negotiated, but whatever bill comes out of the Senate will be more conservative than the House’s bill in several ways. It is not clear that the Senate bill will end up containing a public option, and if it does, unlike the House bill it will allow individual states to opt out of offering it to their residents. The Senate’s bill will also provide fewer subsidies to help low and middle-income people buy insurance, and it will not include a surtax on the rich to offset its new spending.

If these reforms are enacted as outlined in HR 3962, by 2019, CBO estimates:

…the number of nonelderly people who are uninsured would be reduced by about 36 million, leaving about 18 million nonelderly residents uninsured (about one-third of whom would be unauthorized immigrants). Under H.R. 3962, the share of legal nonelderly residents with insurance coverage would rise from about 83 percent currently to about 96 percent. Roughly 21 million people would purchase their own coverage through the new insurance exchanges, and there would be roughly 15 million more enrollees in Medicaid than the total number projected for Medicaid and CHIP combined under current law. (Under the bill, CHIP would no longer exist in 2019.) Relative to currently projected levels, the number of people purchasing individual coverage outside of the exchanges would decrease by about 6 million, and the number obtaining coverage through employers would increase by about 6 million.

If enacted, CBO estimates the impact these reforms could have on the federal budget:

According to CBO and JCT’s assessment, enacting H.R. 3962 would result in a net reduction in federal budget deficits of $104 billion over the 2010– 2019 period (see Table 1). In the subsequent decade, the collective effect of its provisions would probably be slight reductions in federal budget deficits. Those estimates are all subject to substantial uncertainty. The estimate includes a projected net cost of $894 billion over 10 years for the proposed expansions in insurance coverage. That net cost itself reflects a gross total of $1,055 billion in subsidies provided through the exchanges (and related spending), increased net outlays for Medicaid and the

Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP), and tax credits for small employers; those costs are partly offset by $167 billion in collections of penalties paid by individuals and employers. On balance, other effects on revenues and outlays associated with the coverage provisions add $6 billion to their total cost. Over the 2010–2019 period, the net cost of the coverage expansions would be more than offset by the combination of other spending changes, which CBO estimates would save $426 billion, and receipts resulting from the income tax surcharge on high-income individuals and other provisions, which JCT and CBO estimate would increase federal revenues by $572 billion over that period.

Mitch Gurney

House Passes Historic Health Care Bill

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

3 Responses to “H.R. 3962 – The Health Insurance Exchange and Public Option”

  1. Some good info there Mitch.

    Problem I have is that most of us are not able to pay our bills now, so even though 8% sounds like a small amount, it is damn near 10 percent of ones check.

    For instance, if they only bring home 200 dollars now, that means they will only make 180 take home and if any other taxes go up, well hell they’re busted.

    And the really scary one I haven’t seen yet is this.
    If you do not have insurance, you will be fined.
    Whats next?
    Jail?

  2. [...] here to read the rest: H.R. 3962 – The Health Insurance Exchange and Public Option | Keep … Share and [...]

  3. [...] In addition to the bill itself, the two other reports I utilized for this commentary were the HR 3962 Summary Analysis (PDF) and the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) Oct 29th analysis (PDF) of HR 3962. …. But this new public option with negotiated rates is going [to] mean that the health care bill , with its individual mandate, will be forcing healthy people that are currently choosing not to pay hundreds of dollars a month for insurance, to buy insurance without making …More [...]

Leave a Reply

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes